Monday, 12 January 2009

Reflections on Jaroslav Pelikan's "The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition"

Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5, Part 6

The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition (100–600) is the first volume of Jaroslav Pelikan’s five-volume history of Christian doctrine, The Christian Tradition: A History of the Development of Doctrine. Jaroslav Pelikan (1923–2006) was the Sterling Professor of History Emeritus at Yale University and the author of numerous volumes on the history of Christianity.

His The Christian Tradition is truly a massive project, written in clear understanding of its challenging magnitude, as the very first (sober) sentence of volume one’s preface attests: “The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition begins the publication of my history of Christian doctrine, which I hope to complete in five volumes within the next decade” (p. ix).

New quotation system - easy to read

This first volume is based on a study of the primary sources in the original languages – Greek, Syriac, and Latin. The most striking, most original, and most welcomed methodological trait of the whole series is – from the point of view of the average reader – the total absence of not only references to sources within the text but also of all footnotes whatsoever.

The author uses a system of marginal annotations, a system I hope catches on in future monographs too. It serves the interest of both the scholar and layman simultaneously, “without intruding the apparatus of erudition on the reader who is not interested (not yet interested or no longer interested) in the footnotes” (p. x).

The author's strengths

The author’s command of English is excellent, making reading both easy and exhilarating. The dialogue, say, between Greeks and early Christian apologists is at times hilarious, but Pelikan masterfully shows it to be relevant to the development of doctrine (see, for example, the chapter "The Christian Dispute with Classical Thought"). As an example of the author’s style, here is a most clever, apt, concise, and humorous ending to his treatment of the Trinitarian so-called homoousios-homoiousios debate:

“By saying that Christ was ‘of the ousia’ of the Father and ‘like [the Father] in ousia,’ they were, he [Athanasius] continued, ‘settling themselves in opposition to those who say that the Logos is a creature.’ And this was finally the doctrinal interest for which homoousios had been a symbol – coined by the Gnostic heretics, dictated by an unbaptized emperor, jeopardized by naive defenders, but eventually vindicated by its orthodox opponents.” (p. 210.)

The author’s primary sources are, in addition to the ordinary apologetics and "against heresy" material, liturgical and exegetical in nature (see p. 11). He does not “psychoanalyze” the authors of his sources, thank God. He shows wholesome reserve, as psychoanalyzing is, indeed, a questionable tool, especially when wielded across the distance of several centuries.

(As a side note, I will have to make a decision regarding the approach I will take in my own dissertation on John Paul II’s and C.S. Lewis’ conceptions of love. Biographical treatments are undoubtedly needed, and contrary to Pelikan and his subject matter, I and my “subject matter” share closer proximity in time. Although both men, Lewis and John Paul II, left behind a considerable body of personal material (in form of texts), caution must be used as I analyze it.)

Continuing with the author’s strengths, it must be stated that he shows remarkable impartiality and objectivity when dealing with sensitive questions – and this characteristic stands out even without counter-examples, such as Bernhard Lohse, still lingering in my memory. Pelikan, it seems, has refused to borrow “Lohse’s Lutheran lenses”, and nothing in the first volume comes even close to a blatantly one-sided statement, such as Lohse’s, “All the appeals to tradition cannot alter the fact that nowhere does tradition count for less than it does in the Roman church” (History of Christian Doctrine 1985, p. 211).

I was aware of Pelikan’s biographical background and the major transition in his later life. However, without this knowledge, there is little in this first volume that could betray his personal denominational affiliations.

"Church catholic"?

The only exception to this was the expression “church catholic”, which appeared over and over again (e.g. p. 123) and by which I take him to mean the “early Christian mainstream church”. The word order – “church catholic” instead of “catholic church” – stands out.

Why would he use such a clumsy (and revealing?) word order? To make an ecclesiological point (“the early Christian church is not the so-called Catholic Church”)?

If so, it is at the expense of proper English – after all, the volume is named The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition and not The Emergence of the Tradition Catholic – and perhaps invites suspicion of feelings of inferiority. Similarly, I find it amusing that we modern Protestants or non-Catholics insist on saying the Roman Catholic Church instead of simply the Catholic Church (meaning, “Rome has no exclusive rights to the word ‘catholic’!”).

In the next part we move on from more general observation to the substance of the book, to dogma itself and a few interesting dogmatic themes.

Saturday, 10 January 2009

Dialogue in a Dream

I saw some intense dreams the other night. But as I awoke, I could not remember anything about them. Except for one short dialogue between a man and a woman. They obviously knew each other very well. The woman was sad, because she felt the man did not love her.

Woman: "I love you! Why don't you love me?"

Man: "You're in love with me. You don't love me. I'm not in love with you. But I love you."

Thursday, 8 January 2009

Maralyn Mathias (In Memoriam)



A very wonderful woman, Maralyn Mathias, past away last Sunday, 4th of January 2009. For the past 18 months she was suffering -- or living -- with ALS disease, a fatal neuromotorical illness which slowly shuts down all bodily functions. The congnitive function or intellect is usually spared, and Maralyn's blog which she kept during her illness is a remarkable proof of this.

Jesus, thank you for Maralyn and Jim. Embrace her, and comfort and strengthen him. Be with their family.


Below is the last post she wrote just before her death which was published posthumously by her family.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Thirsty for Jesus

[Written early on New Years Day 2009]

Water is essential to life, and even though food will no longer propel down my throat, I’m still drinking. Amazingly, I don’t feel hungry … but I am thirsty, and I’m drinking as much as I possibly can. Without divine intervention, I will get to heaven some time within the month.

These 18 months since my ALS diagnosis have been the worst and best of my life. Worst because of my deteriorating body … best because of my relationship with Christ.

And I’m beginning to see my friendship with Jesus like water when I’m thirsty … so essential to life. He is the real “living water” referred to in John 4:1-26.

I have many lovely friends, but I’ve never before known a Friend SO close. Every day we have smiled, laughed, and cried together. And he has comforted me. I’ve asked his opinion, and he has nodded one way or the other. His close friendship has given me many new perspectives on this earthly life that I had never considered before. He’s been closer than my skin.

This intimate friendship was essential to the writing of this blog. He nudged me and said, “Don’t plan ahead” (totally contrary to my nature). “Let me teach you as we go. I will pick the topics. Just trust me! I’ll show you what to write.”

Let me tell you, for a “Type A” girl, that was tough … at first … until I saw that he really would supply the ideas and insights. It’s been an amazing ride. So if you’ve been blessed by this blog, thank him!

The only thing that makes me sad is realizing that this intimate friendship with him has been available to me all throughout my life, and I never chose it until now. I missed it … big-time! I guess I was always so busy with my lists, projects, plans and events that I was too occupied to be open to such an idea. Oh, I did my devotions, but so often because I knew I “should.” That’s a different thing. Now I long to be with him, to feel his hug, to hear his voice, to see his smile. It’s so different.

Here’s a piece of motherly advice: Don’t wait until you have a terminal illness to seek a true friendship with Jesus. He’s ready! It takes setting aside some less important things. It takes listening. It takes openness. But it’s so worth it! I hope you become literally thirsty for Jesus.

Soon I’ll be in heaven, and it will be great to see the scenery, gardens and mansions. It will be great to hear the singing and see what’s on the banquet tables. BUT! I can tell you, the thing I’m most looking forward to is meeting my Best Friend face-to-face for the very first time. I’m trying to imagine the thrill...

Postscript: Seventy-two hours after writing this, Maralyn Mathias peacefully left this earth to meet her Lord. Her ability to swallow had stopped shortly after completing the above paragraphs. Nevertheless, she remained alert and even communicating with her husband, Jim, and other family members until her final 20 minutes of life. Her last breath was drawn at 10:35 a.m. on Sunday, January 4. She was 59 years old.

Her memorial service will be held on Saturday, January 10, at 10 a.m. at Christian Life Fellowship, Port Edwards, Wis. Visitation will occur at the church on the previous evening (Friday) from 4 to 7 p.m. and again on Saturday morning starting at 9 a.m.

A scholarship in Maralyn’s name will soon be established at Continental Theological Seminary in Brussels, Belgium, where she and Jim served 1987-2000. The specific account for receiving memorial gifts (in lieu of flowers, please) will be announced shortly by e-mail to all subscribers of this blog.

Wednesday, 7 January 2009

Queen and Princess




These pictures say it all. It is clear that the Queen and Princess of my host-family have a sublime bond between them. I cannot wait to see what kind of person Daniella grows up to be. She has a strong will and a robust mind. And yet she is vulnerable and gentle at the same time.


Monday, 5 January 2009

Discussion Continues...

The first of my three political theory questions that I posted some time ago has received several new comments.

Do contribute to the discussion, everybody! This is a joint venture.

Click here.

Sunday, 4 January 2009

A New Year in Africa



This is a short obligatory update. The year 2009 began, for me, in Tanzania. I have been here for one month now. It feels like it just fly by. Five more months of efficient work and play to look forward to. I function and work so much better in a country where the sun rises and sets early. It's been 4 years since I went to bed and got up as early as I do now, willingly.

Some time ago I found out, to my relief, that I was indeed accepted into the University of Helsinki. My dissertation plan (comparative study on two Christian giants' conception of love) was ratified at the same time.

The next four years will be spent in love. Reading about love, writing about it, talking about it, thinking about it, and - to the best of my abilities - living it.

Thursday, 1 January 2009

Triple Party 2009



Yesterday was a great day. We had three reasons to celebrate: Benjy turned 3 years, Daniella 1 year, and history (since Christ's birth) 2009 years. (It's incredible how well Danny and Sirkku timed their kisses.)

Oskar (on the left), is going on his first ever safari this weekend, to Mikumi National Park.

Safari, in Swahili, means simply "a trip". But Oskar's safari will include some amazing animals, too.

Monday, 22 December 2008

The Evolution of Christmas

The meaning of Christmas has changed over the years. Instead of a dry three-page essay on the (d)evolution of Christmas, here's a simple three-point illustration.


Big Bang (1AD-ca.1700AD)
"For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have life everlasting." (John 3:16)


Reptilian Age (1700AD-2000AD)
"Give some, take some. Be nice, take more."


Homo Modernicus (2000AD--?)

Sunday, 21 December 2008

Not "Hot" In Swahili

It's +33 degrees Celcius in Dar es Salaam, but it's not hot. Well, not in Finnish anyway. Hot in Finnish is kuuma. Unfortunately, kuuma is also a Swahili word meaning something quite different -- it's a part of human anatomy, woman's anatomy to be more precise.

So all the Finns here say it's lämmin (warm).

To spice things up further, the Finnish No onpa kuuma! means "Wow it's hot!" But no onpa, when one says it quickly, sounds a lot the Swahili word namba which means "may I have?". Summa summarum: shouting No onpa kuuma! in public (like in a restaurant during peak hours) will raise a few eyebrows and cause a chainreaction of chuckles.